Cinnamon Lake Homes with Black River LSD - 5201 School District

Welcome to Cinnamon Lake, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of West Salem, Ohio, within the picturesque Ashland County. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of tranquility and community spirit, making it an ideal place for families and individuals alike.

Cinnamon Lake is renowned for its stunning natural beauty, featuring serene lakes, lush greenery, and a variety of recreational opportunities. Residents can enjoy leisurely strolls along the scenic paths, fishing in the tranquil waters, or simply basking in the sun at the community beach. The atmosphere here is one of warmth and camaraderie, with neighbors often coming together for community events and gatherings.

The homes in Cinnamon Lake are as diverse as its residents, offering a range of styles and sizes to suit any lifestyle. From cozy retreats perfect for small families to spacious residences ideal for those looking to entertain, there’s something for everyone. Each property is thoughtfully designed, often featuring modern amenities and beautiful outdoor spaces that enhance the overall living experience.

Families will appreciate the strong educational foundation provided by the Black River Local School District (LSD), which serves the area. With a commitment to academic excellence, the district offers a supportive environment for students to thrive, ensuring that your children receive a quality education.

Whether you’re seeking a peaceful weekend getaway or a permanent residence in a friendly community, Cinnamon Lake is the perfect place to call home. Discover the charm and beauty of this wonderful subdivision today, and step into a lifestyle defined by comfort, community, and connection.

Newest Cinnamon Lake Homes with Black River LSD - 5201 School District

$295,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 5234951 MLS

Welcome home to 3313 Acuminata where the view is timeless and the possibilities are endless. Imagine starting your mornings with coffee overlooking the water, fishing from your own shoreline, and ending the day with dinner on the deck as the sun reflects across the lake. A gently graded shoreline offers effortless access to the water, creating the lakefront lifestyle you've been dreaming of. Inside, you'll find a home ready for its next chapter. Full of charm and opportunity, it invites you to bring your vision and make it your own. The main level offers two bedrooms, two full bathrooms, for convenient single-floor living. The finished walkout lower level adds even more possibilities with a second kitchen, full bath, and workspace perfect for guests, multigenerational living, or a private retreat. If you've been searching for a waterfront home where you can build equity while creating something uniquely yours, this could be the one. Discover why so many love calling Cinnamon Lake home.

3313 Acuminata Drive, West Salem

$265,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5229127 MLS

Waterfront Living in Cinnamon Lake! Enjoy lakefront living in this beautiful 2-bedroom, 2-bath home with a possible 3rd bedroom or office. The main living area features a cozy fireplace and cathedral ceilings, creating an open, inviting space with scenic lake views. The spacious primary suite offers a walk-in closet, private en-suite bath, and its own balcony overlooking the water. Step outside to a wraparound deck, perfect for relaxing or entertaining, along with three new powered docks providing convenient access to the lake. A large garage with a workshop offers ample space for vehicles, storage, hobbies, or projects, while a storage shed adds even more functionality. This waterfront property is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy the recreational amenities and peaceful lifestyle that Cinnamon Lake has to offer. PLEASE ALLOW 48 HOURS for response to any offers

1197 Ginko Drive, West Salem

$1,375,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 5222581 MLS

Custom Lodge-Style Estate in Private Gated Lake Community Welcome to this extraordinary custom-built lodge-style estate where handcrafted craftsmanship, luxury finishes, and thoughtful design create a truly one-of-a-kind home. Located in a private gated lake community, this exceptional property offers approximately 5,200 finished square feet, 5 bedrooms, 5.5 bathrooms, two kitchens, two laundry areas, and a finished 45' x 30' two-story shop with drive-through capability and two 12' x 14' overhead doors. Designed for entertaining and everyday living, the home showcases soaring ceilings, exposed timber beams, stone fireplaces, live-edge woodwork, custom cabinetry, premium flooring, a loft overlooking the great room, and a whole-home Sonos sound system. The gourmet kitchen features stone countertops, an oversized island, built-in appliances, and a handcrafted live-edge dining table. Four bedrooms each feature a private full bath and walk-in closet, creating four true suites. The owner's suite includes a luxury walk-in closet, spa-style bath with a heated jetted tub, oversized tile shower, and direct access to the second-story shop. Additional highlights include a dedicated office, full gym, security system with hardwired cameras, natural gas, metal roof, tankless water heater, stamped and stained concrete, mature Norway spruce trees for privacy, and a four-tier deck with seasonal lake views. Residents enjoy access to a 127-acre lake, beach, swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, and the privacy of gated community living. Unless the buyer prefers otherwise, the home is being offered fully furnished, with nearly all furnishings and décor transferring with the property. This is a rare opportunity to own a custom-crafted estate offering exceptional quality, luxury amenities, and a lifestyle that is nearly impossible to replicate.A true must-see property that must be appreciated in person to fully capture its detail, craftsmanship, and presence.

3255 Curaso Drive, West Salem

$4,900

5190093 MLS

5038 Maderia Drive, West Salem

$13,900

5086295 MLS

Cinnamon Lake is located in the scenic heart of Ohio Amish country. Situated in the Northeastern part of Ashland County just outside of West Salem. Over 1200 acres encompass the private development which includes over 200 acres of common areas and a 135 acre lake that only allows non-gas engines which makes the lake one of the quietest. Kayaks, canoes and other non-powered watercraft are also allowed. In addition, Cinnamon Lake has a sand filled beach in front of the lodge. Other amenities that members have access to include a 4,500 sq. ft. lodge with concession stand, restrooms and showers – it’s a great place to hold large events such as weddings, receptions, birthday parties, etc. Members enjoy a swimming pool, basketball courts, tennis courts, sand volleyball & a playground. Wet & dry docks for use are available for a fee to members. Golf carts are allowed. The lake is stocked with Largemouth Bass, Bullheads, Saugeye, Crappie, & Yellow Perch to name a few! The north side of the lake has a softball field with restrooms and there are pavilions and picnic areas for members to use, and a full service campground with electric and water hookups. Cinnamon Lake is a short 7 minute drive from West Salem, 20 minutes from Ashland, 90 minutes from Columbus, and 1-hour from Cleveland. Less than 10 minutes from Dragway 42.

1129-1130 Cinnamon Drive, West Salem

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of MLS Now and updated as of . Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Fessler Real Estate Group / REMAX Infinity are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing broker(s).
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 MLS Now. All Rights Reserved.